Quest's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Anj_Shadows]

Why the AI generated artwork?

Anjovi responds:

I like the visual anchor that the art evokes and how easy it is to get a rough representation of what I was imagining while writing. It's not the centerpiece, but it helps. Commissioning actual artists or teaching myself to visual art like this would simply be overkill for what is essentially a thumbnail.

[my 6 4 type beat]

A little wonky, but it sounds like music, so you're obviously doing something right. Minor gripe is that it is extremely repetitive.

Zambies responds:

My main goal was to use that sample for everything

[Journey- Separate Ways (Worlds Apart) - Cover]

My favorite song, covered right.

YoriYakuza responds:

Thanks, glad you like it!

[Geometry Dash Typebeat]

This is really, really good. I originally thought this was just going to be a crappy remix or verbatim upload of another song, but this is original. Something actually unique. Glad to see you on Newgrounds.

TimRick responds:

Wow, thank you for the response! I genuinely never expected so much praise from my work ever and I really appreciate all the kind words.

[Voyage to Everywhere]

It's clear to see you put a lot of time into this, it sounds so good. I'm gonna go find some more chipstep now.

jamatar responds:

Thanks for listening 🙏❤️

[Necromancy (2023 Remake)]

Intense and somehow nostalgic. I need to fight a dark wizard to this song.

Catpocalypse responds:

Go get that wizard!

[Skanker]

I agree, this should be played at high volume!

Preds responds:

yusssss!!!

[NPC]

The lyrics are very clever. The story you told is such a relatable feeling, perfectly wrapped in the metaphor of an NPC. I feel the same way much of the time. While I don't want to achieve anything grand in my life, I still want to grab the controller and do something. But every time I try to reach for it though, it always feels too far away, or I just lack the motivation to grab it, or do anything for that matter. Honestly, simply "moving on" is hard enough as it is. I hate the lane that I'm in, yet I stick to it, because I can't find a way to do anything else. All in all, these lyrics are powerful in the way they convey emotion and the universal experience of depression.

My only criticism is that I wish there was a bit more instrumentation (or at least something different) at 1:09. Then again, I'm not sure something different (or a drop) would really benefit the track, as it might defeat the purpose of the mellow tone. I'm not a musician or a composer though, so I really don't know.

Other than that though, this is a great piece! I look forward to seeing more of your work in the future. Thank you for this song.

DJ-AfterBurnz responds:

Thank you…I’m sorry I haven’t been able to deliver to your expectations… I’m Not the best. I just want to make stuff to help my depression.

[Synth V Vocals test]

I'd rather not dive into the ethics of AI in music creation, so I'll mostly talk about the song. Honestly, the vocals sound fine. They sound a bit generic in places, but other than that, they would pass as a real voice if you had not said that it was AI. It sounds great. Everything else sounds great too, and I would love to hear an instrumental version of this.

One last thing, just remember, it's not a one way trip. I don't know why you would think that.

NahuPyrope responds:

Thank you!, I'm not good at doing either lyrics or vocal lines, I'm strictly an instrumental artist!.

Having AI vocals changes the world for me, I've worked with many, many vocalists but always on songs that are someone else's or collaborations, I like being mostly independent when it comes to making music for myself so having an easy way to just go *plop* and put vocals into a song I've made is super freeing!, I know it's not a one way trip, but it does feel just *amazing* to have vocals haha.

About the ethics of AI in music creation well, I don't think of it as a voice, nothing ever will replace the human voice, but it is a tool, another instrument, just like some people use guitars VSTs because they can't play (or afford) guitar and all it's equipment, there's no replacing the real thing!.

Thank you for your comment!, the song is very, very not done and still an extreme WIP, I didn't compose it with the idea of it having vocals and this is just like, an hour of messing with the program and writing the cheesy lyrics, but I wanted to share my findings with the world!