00:00
00:00
Quest

224 Audio Reviews w/ Response

All 826 Reviews

0 reviews are hidden due to your filters.

Pretty good, although I feel not much was added when compared to the original track. There's a few new layers to the sound and some much needed variety was added, but it still falls short for me. I wish there was more. In my opinion, the original song wasn't that interesting to begin with, and although you improved on it, your derivative work is still held back by the monotony and dullness from which it is based on. An extra melody or something to make it more interesting would have been a welcome addition. I still think you (and this song) have potential, but it just wasn't that interesting to me. Remember, this is just my opinion, others may think of it differently.

ObeyGDBot responds:

Okay

What software did you use?

Bluecrystalpart2 responds:

I use garageband ;-;

Did you use bandlab loops? If so, your music could get taken down, just a warning.

Katzw1n responds:

I don't use loops on bandlab unless i need percussion sounds

Why the AI generated artwork?

Anjovi responds:

I like the visual anchor that the art evokes and how easy it is to get a rough representation of what I was imagining while writing. It's not the centerpiece, but it helps. Commissioning actual artists or teaching myself to visual art like this would simply be overkill for what is essentially a thumbnail.

A little wonky, but it sounds like music, so you're obviously doing something right. Minor gripe is that it is extremely repetitive.

Zambies responds:

My main goal was to use that sample for everything

My favorite song, covered right.

YoriYakuza responds:

Thanks, glad you like it!

This is really, really good. I originally thought this was just going to be a crappy remix or verbatim upload of another song, but this is original. Something actually unique. Glad to see you on Newgrounds.

TimRick responds:

Wow, thank you for the response! I genuinely never expected so much praise from my work ever and I really appreciate all the kind words.

Trust Not The System.

Also known as "Questtrek".

I make art and occasionally games.

🩷💜💙

I always try to give the best feedback possible.

I am open to playtesting if you want another opinion.

Death to AI!

Feel free to PM me about anyting.

California

Joined on 4/8/21

Level:
16
Exp Points:
2,760 / 2,840
Exp Rank:
21,571
Vote Power:
5.83 votes
Rank:
Portal Security
Global Rank:
24,924
Blams:
27
Saves:
374
B/P Bonus:
8%
Whistle:
Deity
Trophies:
8
Medals:
73
Supporter:
17d